SlotCafesIllinois
21+
Gaming location

The Old Mill

Legal name: Cynthia Simpson

4194 E. 2603 Rd., Sheridan, IL, 60551

Historical payout · last 12 months

87.43%

About $87.43 paid back per $100 played · $175K played

Year to date

88.04%

9 months

Machines

3 of 6

Reported September 2026

Low confidence — Based on 12 reported months and $175K played. Confidence reflects how much data supports this figure, not the quality of the venue.All players, state reports through September 2026. Not a prediction of your next visit.Payout history
Google MapsApple Maps

Opening hours and machine availability today aren’t confirmed. Check with the business before visiting.

Location matched to the street address by the U.S. Census geocoder.

Payout history

State reports through September 2026. Past play across all players, not a prediction of your next visit. Amount played includes re-played credits.

The line is observed payout. The bars beneath are how much was played that month — a percentage on a quiet month rests on less evidence.

71.9%88.7%105.5%$29K$14K$0Jun ’24: 91.88% on $18K playedJul ’24: 87.87% on $19K playedAug ’24: 87.44% on $12K playedSep ’24: 89.56% on $14K playedOct ’24: 99.82% on $29K playedNov ’24: 87.44% on $27K playedDec ’24: 83.34% on $12K playedJan ’25: 80.90% on $10K playedFeb ’25: 100.62% on $20K playedMar ’25: 89.08% on $23K playedApr ’25: 86.77% on $19K playedMay ’25: 93.68% on $17K playedJun ’25: 88.67% on $14K playedJul ’25: 72.65% on $7K playedAug ’25: 88.66% on $16K playedSep ’25: 102.44% on $11K playedOct ’25: 91.77% on $16K playedNov ’25: 79.32% on $24K playedDec ’25: 91.89% on $11K playedJan ’26: 81.89% on $10K playedFeb ’26: 88.74% on $8K playedMar ’26: 84.91% on $20K playedApr ’26: 104.70% on $9K playedMay ’26: 100.63% on $9K playedJun ’26: 94.81% on $17K playedJul ’26: 84.00% on $21K playedAug ’26: 80.82% on $21K playedSep ’26: 85.67% on $9K playedJun ’24Nov ’24Apr ’25Sep ’25Feb ’26Jul ’26Sep ’26
View these figures as a table
Monthly amount played, amount won and observed payout.
MonthPlayedWonHistorical payout
Sep ’26$9K$8K85.67%
Aug ’26$21K$17K80.82%
Jul ’26$21K$17K84.00%
Jun ’26$17K$16K94.81%
May ’26$9K$9K100.63%
Apr ’26$9K$9K104.70%
Mar ’26$20K$17K84.91%
Feb ’26$8K$7K88.74%
Jan ’26$10K$8K81.89%
Dec ’25$11K$10K91.89%
Nov ’25$24K$19K79.32%
Oct ’25$16K$14K91.77%
Sep ’25$11K$11K102.44%
Aug ’25$16K$14K88.66%
Jul ’25$7K$5K72.65%
Jun ’25$14K$12K88.67%
May ’25$17K$16K93.68%
Apr ’25$19K$17K86.77%
Mar ’25$23K$21K89.08%
Feb ’25$20K$20K100.62%
Jan ’25$10K$8K80.90%
Dec ’24$12K$10K83.34%
Nov ’24$27K$24K87.44%
Oct ’24$29K$29K99.82%
Sep ’24$14K$12K89.56%
Aug ’24$12K$10K87.44%
Jul ’24$19K$17K87.87%
Jun ’24$18K$17K91.88%
Detailed historical data
PeriodHistorical payoutPlayedConfidence
HIST. PAYOUT · 2026 YTD9 mo88.04%$124KLow confidence — Based on 9 reported months and $124K played. Confidence reflects how much data supports this figure, not the quality of the venue.
HIST. PAYOUT · 3 MO.3 mo83.00%$51KLow confidence — Based on 3 reported months and $51K played. Confidence reflects how much data supports this figure, not the quality of the venue.
HIST. PAYOUT · 6 MO.6 mo89.44%$86KLow confidence — Based on 6 reported months and $86K played. Confidence reflects how much data supports this figure, not the quality of the venue.
HIST. PAYOUT · 12 MO.12 mo87.43%$175KLow confidence — Based on 12 reported months and $175K played. Confidence reflects how much data supports this figure, not the quality of the venue.
HIST. PAYOUT · 24 MO.24 mo89.34%$380KMedium confidence — Based on 24 reported months and $380K played. Confidence reflects how much data supports this figure, not the quality of the venue.
HIST. PAYOUT · ALL HISTORY28 mo89.34%$443KMedium confidence — Based on 28 reported months and $443K played. Confidence reflects how much data supports this figure, not the quality of the venue.

More in Sheridan

All places in Sheridan →

Before you visit

Hours
Not provided. Check with the business before making a trip.
Reported machines
3 in September 2026. This is a historical count, not live availability.
Record source
Address and license details from Illinois Gaming Board records (Establishment, license 120707115). Gaming reports available on this site through September 2026. Latest report for this location: September 2026. How sources are used
Browse more in SheridanBrowse Illinois citiesSearch nearby

Own or manage this location?

Claim this business to add photos, hours, amenities, links and business details. Official gaming statistics and result ordering remain independent.

Claim This Business

Figures come from Illinois Gaming Board monthly reports. Full methodology. Must be 21+.